Ryan Seacrest: (Introduction) ...and Andrea will be here tomorrow night singing live... but starting us off tonight, it is Kat! Let's see how it went with Andrea and David. Watch...
Intro clip... Katharine: (To camera) I'm singing "I Have Nothing". It was made famous by Whitney Houston and it was actually written by David Foster.
David Foster: (In rehearsals alongside Andrea and Katharine) You know I... I wrote this song Andrea.
Andrea Bocelli: Who?
David: Me.
Andrea: Really?
Katharine: You wrote it.
Andrea: Wow!
Katharine: (To camera) Going in there I was, I was really nervous.
Katharine: (Singing for Andrea and David in rehearsals) ¯ Don't make me close one more door ¯
Katharine: (To camera) It was a lot of pressure for me.
David: In the key change you could go... (Changes the phrasing, Andrea hums) ¯ Don't make me ¯ Close ¯ One more door ¯
Katharine: Oh, that's good.
David: I mean, if...
Katharine: Okay.
David: ...if you nail that...
Katharine: Okay.
David: Can we try that?
Katharine: (To camera) It kind of felt like how it would be in a recording studio.
David and Katharine: (Rehearsals) ¯ Don't make me me ¯ Close ¯ One More Door ¯
David: (To camera) I think Katharine has a great, great future.
Andrea: (To Andrea in rehearsals) Honestly the voice is very beautiful.
Katharine: Oh, thank you.
Andrea: Powerful and clean.
Katharine: Cool!
David: Could... could she sing opera do you think?
Andrea: Ah, probably, yes! Stunning, yah.
Katharine: (Bursts into The Prayer/La Preghiera 
, recorded by Andrea Bocelli and Celine Dion) ¯ La luce che tu dai ¯
Katharine: (To camera, laughing) Andrea and I just started like having this full on duet!
Andrea and Katharine: ¯ Un mondo di giustizia e di speranza ¯
Andrea: (Taps David)
David: Yes?
Andrea: You have to say also that she is nice. Beautiful (laughs) and young! And this... it's important.
David: How do you know all this?
Andrea: Don't worry. (Smiles and taps David)
David: (Laughs heartily)
Andrea: Don't care! (Laughs)
David: (Grinning) Okay.
Katharine sings...
¯ Share my life ¯ Take me for what I am ¯ 'Cause I'll never change ¯ All my colors for you ¯ I don't really need to look ¯ Very much further ¯ I don't wanna have to go ¯ Where you don't follow ¯ I will hold it back again ¯ This passion inside ¯ Can't run from myself ¯ There's nowhere to hide ¯ Don't make me close one more door ¯ I don't wanna hurt anymore ¯ Stay in my arms if you dare ¯ Or must I imagine you there ¯ Don't walk away from me ¯ Oh ¯ I have nothing, nothing, nothing ¯ Don't make me close one more door ¯ I don't wanna hurt anymore ¯ Stay in my arms if you dare ¯ Or must I imagine you there ¯ Don't walk away from me ¯ Oh ¯ Don't walk away from me ¯ Don't you dare ¯ Don't you dare walk a way from me ¯ I have nothing, nothing, nothing ¯ If I don't have you ¯ (Cheers and applause) Randy Jackson: Whoa... a'ight. So I was ah... I must say I was a little bit worried about this week, because, you know, great love songs... It was probably a good choice of a song but I honestly think, just keepin' it real... it was way too big for you.
Katharine: (Nods, but shows her disappointment)
Randy Jackson: This song... I mean all the runs... (Loud groans and boos from the audience) ... You're talkin' about copyin' a song, singin' a song... Whitney Houston in her prime, who's one of the best singers in the known world... That didn't come close baby, I'm sorry.
Katharine: (Pulls a disappointed face, then laughs)
Paula Abdul: (The audience is still booing as Paula begins) I'm gonna start by saying, as usual, you are stunning.
Katharine: (Smiles) Thank you.
Paula Abdul: Um, It's really tough in this competition now. It's serious and tough, and I'm gonna try to be a little bit on that, on that side. Um, there were pitch problems. I gotta tell you... Going back to last week when you... when you sang... that was just zoned. When you don't push your vocals, when you are singing in your natural voice and... and you singin' with your false voice an' it's... you don't have to be onstage and oversing 'cause sometimes what happens is you tend to fall a little flat when you hit the power notes. Having said that, this is a tough song to sing. It's very difficult to sing.
Randy Jackson: Hard, very hard.
Paula Abdul: You... you are a star. You are born to sing. Watch... (Katharine smiles) ...know what your money is. Your mo... the back pocket... what your, your money is. And your money is your intimate vocal.
Katharine: (Smiles at Paula, bites on her tongue)
Paula Abdul: That's what I feel. Other than that, you know...
Katharine: Thank you.
Paula Abdul: ...you are a star.
Katharine: Thank you.
Simon Cowell: (To Paula) I didn't really understand what you were saying there.
Paula Abdul: Well, somebody did.
Simon Cowell: Money? Back-pocket? Don't think she did!
Randy Jackson: Cowell, you have money in your pocket?
Simon Cowell: Katharine. Very simple. By choosing that song it is like coming out here and saying "I am as good as Whitney Houston".
Randy Jackson: Yeah.
Simon Cowell: You're not.
Katharine: (Smiles, then grimaces)
Simon Cowell: That was the problem. I also thought it was quite old fashioned and actually quite cabaret. So I think you went backwards there, because if you're gonna sing a song a... like a Whitney song, you've got to be as good!
Randy Jackson: Yeah. Right.
Simon Cowell: And what you told us was... you're not! Bad advice. (Boos)
Ryan Seacrest: (Greets Katharine on stage) Well! Bit of an uncomfortable start to the party.
Katharine: (Indistinct)
Ryan Seacrest: Ya. Well for those who don't have their volume on I'm sure you're gonna get plenty of votes. Brave moves in that dress rolling around here up on the stage.
Katharine: Thank you.
Ryan Seacrest: You look beautiful tonight.
Katharine: Thank you Ryan.
Ryan Seacrest: They're certainly tough this evening. (Ryan gives out the voting numbers) Thank you Katharine.
Katharine: (Smiling) Thank you!