Ryan Seacrest: Now, time for farm girl. She's chosen 'Making Love Out Of Nothing At All', it is by Air Supply. Give it up once again for Carrie Underwood.
Carrie sings...
Clive Davis: Carrie that song choice was very special to me. I shared that number one hit with Air Supply. I love the fact that you threw yourself into it. You did it with conviction. Your voice soared. Great job.
Carrie: Thank you. (Applause - Carrie smiles)
Randy Jackson: I said it before I'll say it again... Carrie, you can definitely, definitely sing. Every time you come up there and open your mouth, I'm looking forward to hearing you sing because you can blow dude! (Applause)
Carrie: Thank you very much.
Paula Abdul: It was a great choice of song because you really got to really power your voice, which you do so brilliantly and effortlessly. Great... you sang it great... unbelievable.
Carrie: Thank you. Thank you.
Simon Cowell: Carrie, you... you've had a good night tonight. I think you ... I think you sang the first song better. Ahm, I wouldn't have liked to have followed Bo... (Laughter)
Carrie: (Jokey) No!
Simon Cowell: ...after that... right. Ahm, I think you may have pushed that song too much in the middle. That's what it sounded like to me. It was straining a bit. They don't agree but...
Randy Jackson: Noooo... no!
Simon Cowell: ...I don't know.
Ryan Seacrest: You decide at home. Carrie's numbers ...